1 Comment
User's avatar
ā­  Return to thread
Cindy Marette's avatar

Absolutely agree with your concerns. While the LOTR trilogy was fantastic (though imperfect as I’m a ā€œbook firstā€ person), the Hobbit movies were quite the disappointment for me.

I felt the Rings of Power were fine, and maybe even more than fine… the 2nd season should even be better. Until the creative makers are granted access to the Silmarillion, there will be just a Marvelization of the same material. I’m not even convinced the Silmarillion should be anything more than the gorgeous, grand, nearly holy treasure it is. Small ā€˜h’ holy lest someone gets concerned, as they tend to these days…

Expand full comment
ErrorError